Impact of H-1B Visas on US-Indian Relations

In light of the recent policy guidance from the US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) regarding the screening of family-based immigrant visa petitions, there has been a rising demand within the US to completely eliminate H-1B visas. However, many netizens have highlighted that these H-1B visas, particularly for Indian nationals, have significantly benefited the United States.

According to mutual fund distributor D Muthukrishnan, Indians have made substantial contributions to America. He stated that this community does not get involved in disputes or violence and abides by the laws of their host country. The concern arises from their achievements, as Indians are now among the wealthiest groups in the US. With the highest rates of college and higher education, some factions of the MAGA movement believe that Indians have succeeded at the expense of Americans. There is a growing animosity driven by jealousy, causing resentment towards both India and its people.

“Indians have contributed a lot to America. They respect the laws of the land and focus on education,” Muthukrishnan remarked. “Their success has unfortunately bred animosity, as those left behind seek someone to blame.”

Angel investor Rushabh Shah echoed these sentiments, noting that Indians have always stood out in the US, not by creating discord, but by making a positive impact. He highlighted their adherence to rules and their contributions in various fields such as medicine, engineering, teaching, science, and entrepreneurship. “The belief that Indians ‘took jobs’ from Americans is fundamentally flawed—Indians earned their positions,” Shah stated. He emphasized that a prosperous America should not equate to a declining India.

Shah elaborated, saying, “Indian H-1B workers send $30 billion back in remittances. This visa is not a leverage point over India; it is mutually beneficial, with the US reaping significant rewards.”

Sidharth, a US-based Indian tech entrepreneur, also expressed his views, urging his fellow Americans to think critically and not be swayed by foreign-funded narratives or opportunistic individuals who have limited experience in technology. He pointed out India’s economy, valued at $4.3 trillion, and the notable remittances sent back to India by H-1B workers.

Congresswoman Marjorie Taylor Greene added a political dimension to this discussion, suggesting that President Trump should “further punish India” by replacing H-1B visas with American jobs. Her remarks have intensified the political dialogue surrounding immigration, coinciding with heightened trade tensions between India and the US. According to USCIS data from 2024, 70 per cent of all H-1B visas are issued to Indian nationals.