AI’s Impact on Career Ladders

AI has sparked a global dialogue focused on a pressing concern: will robots replace human jobs? The emphasis on unemployment data paints a bleak picture of a world void of human contribution. However, amidst this obsession, a crucial shift regarding the quality of careers is frequently overlooked.

The Core Threat of AI

The main issue posed by AI pertains to the dismantling of the traditional career ladder. Instead of wiping out the job market entirely, AI is eroding the path that once connected entry-level positions to expert roles.

Understanding Mastery Development

To grasp this better, one must explore how professional skills have historically been developed. For many years, the journey to becoming an expert followed a well-defined trajectory. Individuals would start from the ground up, managing basic tasks.

For instance, junior lawyers devoted years to scrutinising laborious contracts. Junior developers focused on writing straightforward, repetitive code. Similarly, junior marketers crafted countless subject lines in search of effective ones.

Although this work was often viewed as tedious, it played an essential role in shaping expertise. It was a process of ‘learning by osmosis.’ By grappling with basic tasks, junior employees internalised the core principles of their professions.

They recognised what constitutes a good contract by analysing numerous flawed ones, and learned the intricacies of systems by resolving minor bugs. However, AI is now capable of automating this fundamental learning. Tools such as ChatGPT and GitHub Copilot can efficiently handle these basic tasks in an instant.

Consequences of Non-Linear Experience

This automation brings extraordinary efficiency to organisations, yet it simultaneously undermines the essential learning framework. The removal of mundane tasks eradicates the arena where the next generation of leaders would traditionally develop their skills.

This situation leads to a workforce characterised by non-linear experiences. In the past, employees transitioned from apprentices to journeymen and then to masters. Today, AI enables beginners to leapfrog directly into a supervisory role.

A junior employee can create prompts for AI to execute tasks and review the results. While this appears to empower younger workers, it cultivates a precarious form of expertise.

The Dangers of Fragile Expertise

This fragile expertise can be perilous when complications arise. If AI produces inaccurate or misleading information, the ability to recognise these errors necessitates deep foundational knowledge. When employees skip the essential learning curve, they may overlook these discrepancies entirely.

Simply put, the workforce risks being composed of individuals who cannot identify a malfunction, much like allowing drivers unfamiliar with manual transmission to handle high-speed vehicles.

Challenges for Organisational Health

This disintegration of the career ladder spells considerable challenges for organisational well-being. Traditionally, companies have depended on ‘internal compounding’—hiring eager young talent, instilling company methods, and eventually nurturing them into future leaders who embody the organisational ethos.

When the foundational career ladder is rendered ineffective, this natural growth process becomes increasingly challenging. Juniors cannot gain experience on entry-level tasks since AI undertakes them. As a result, they are deprived of the context essential for advancing to senior positions.

Creating External Dependency

This scenario drives organisations toward external reliance. Companies may struggle to promote from within, as their talent pool comprises ‘overseers’ rather than genuine experts. To address these gaps, businesses will likely resort to hiring costly senior talent or bringing in consultants.

This shift fosters a culture akin to mercenaries, where the rich institutional knowledge informing past decisions diminishes. Organisations may devolve into a mere collection of tools and contractors, rather than a unified group of developing professionals.

The Need for a New Approach

Now is the time to redirect the conversation from potential job loss to the strategies required for cultivating the experts of tomorrow. Without the foundational rungs on the career ladder due to automation, ascending to higher levels becomes nearly unfeasible.

The upcoming decade must focus on redefining apprenticeship. It is vital to establish new methods for conveying tacit knowledge to successive generations. Failing to do so may result in a workforce full of managers, while the individuals capable of executing the work remain absent.

The post Why AI Will Not Kill Jobs, But Will Kill Career Ladders appeared first on StartupSuperb Media.